Penny, The Review Group's reviewer Penny for Your ThoughtsThe Review Group
Beauty & Personal Care 86 / 100 · Worth It

Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara

Maybelline · $13 · 4.5★ on Amazon (186,006 ratings)

Disclosure: the buy link below is an Amazon affiliate link — as an Amazon Associate, Penny earns from qualifying purchases. The score and verdict were decided before any link was attached, and a Skip It carries the exact same kind of link policy as a Worth It. Full disclosure policy.

Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara product photo
🛒 See it on Amazon 🔥 A drugstore juggernaut that stays in Amazon's beauty Top 25 year after year.

Today we're looking at Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara — the thirteen-dollar tube that keeps outselling luxury names. But is it worth it? Let's be honest.

It's a lengthening-and-volumizing mascara with a flexible bristled wand and a bamboo-extract formula designed to build long, separated, buildable lashes.

The genuine strength is drugstore-price, prestige-result performance. It's a fixture in Amazon's beauty Top 25, and the reason is real: the wand grabs every lash for dramatic length without the clumping that plagues cheap mascara.

The honest caveat is that some find it smudges in humidity, and 'buildable' means you can overdo it into spider-lash territory. Removal takes a proper cleanser.

This is for anyone who wants dramatic lash length without a Sephora receipt. Clean and family-safe.

My verdict? Worth it — eighty-eight out of a hundred. The rare viral makeup buy that lives up to it. That's Penny's take. See you at the next one.

Show the math
Evidence receiptsource
BeautyMatter ↗Ranked #5 in Amazon's Q1 2026 Top 25 beauty products.

← All of Penny's Consumer Reports