Penny, The Review Group's reviewer Penny for Your ThoughtsThe Review Group
Children's ✓ Reviewed

Case of the Maestro's Ghost/The Case of the Second Sight

John Whitman · 1999
93/100
👍 Worth It

Shirley Holmes — great-grandniece of the great detective — investigates a school disappearance and a second mystery in this two-story tie-in volume from John Whitman's 1999 novelization series. The formula is clean: a smart, observant female protagonist applies Holmesian logic to modern mysteries for middle-grade readers. The ghost in the title is treated as a puzzle to be solved, not horror to endure, which keeps the content squarely age-appropriate. The honest caveat is that this book is a companion to a Canadian TV series, not a stand-alone literary work, and readers unfamiliar with the show will miss some context. For fans of the series or parents looking for logic-forward mysteries with a capable girl lead, it delivers what it promises.

📚 Buy the book 📱 Read on Kindle 🎧 Listen on Audible affiliate links · support the site, never the verdict
As an Amazon Associate and Audible affiliate, Penny earns from qualifying purchases. This never affects the verdict — see our affiliate disclosure.
Show the math
Verdict receipt0–100
Public sentiment (amazon.com)100%98
Penny’s verdict93
Worth your time next
R
✓ Penny Approved creator
Read Aloud Revival (Sarah Mackenzie)
For the grown-up choosing the books — a trusted, family-friendly guide to read-alouds worth your shelf.
✓ Vetted · education, not advice
Cross-pollinate